Zoe and Dale, hosts of the declining cryptid hunt streaming web show, Cryptid Casefiles, are in immediate danger of cancellation. After an anonymous tip hints at the location of the mysterious Mothman, the hosts venture into the woods of West Virginia to find Mothman and have a chance at salvaging their sinking ship of a show. Unfortunately for them, other cryptids crash in a ploy to maintain relevance since most cryptids have been revealed to mankind, with the exception of Mothman. While these hijinks ensue, Zoe weighs what it means to be a content creator and whether or not salvaging this show is what she truly wants.